Thursday, September 30, 2010

The World’s Greatest Entertainer in His Prime: Al Jolson on Columbia 1913-1932

When in 1927 Al Jolson stood in front of the camera and proclaimed, “You ain’t heard nothin’ yet!” he was using the phrase to refer to the much-publicized novelty of the movie in which he was starring, The Jazz Singer, now widely considered the first talking picture of all time even though it was actually just a part-talkie, that is, a silent film interspersed with a few sound scenes. Jolson’s utterance may have applied to the movie, yet it most certainly did not apply to Jolson himself: the public had heard quite a bit from Jolson by 1927, which was the reason why he had been selected to play the leading role in a film whose script, by Samson Raphaelson, strangely echoed Jolson’s own life story. In fact, it was virtually impossible to be interested in pop music in the 1910s and 20s and not have heard of Jolson, the bombastic vocalist who billed himself as “the world’s greatest entertainer” and had become the most popular singing sensation in the country.

Despite the title of that groundbreaking film, though, Jolson never was strictly a jazz singer: he could be more accurately described as a pop singer whose work was occasionally tinged by the jazz idiom and who knew how to use jazz syncopation to his advantage, thereby creating a very appealing dramatic effect. Of course, drama featured prominently in Jolson’s approach to the vocal art: in the days prior to the invention of the microphone, his impressive, energetic voice could effortlessly fill any theater, and it sounded equally exciting on his signature sentimental mammy songs as it did on the most jazz-influenced of his rhythm numbers. His stage show brimmed with emotion and unrestrained energy, and both his antics and his exuberant vocal style influenced just about everyone in show business, at least until Bing Crosby came along in the early 1930s and showed the world that there was an alternative, more intimate approach to popular singing. But by then, the microphone had already entered the picture, changing the face of popular music forever. The new style heralded by Crosby sent some of the earlier singers, who now sounded desperately old-fashioned, out of business, yet Jolson still enjoyed quite a following on radio and movies throughout the 1930s, making no efforts to modify his style to suit the new technical advancements. The release of the excellent biopic The Jolson Story in 1946, starring Larry Parks and William Demarest (as well as the inferior but equally charming sequel Jolson Sings Again, from three years later) revived interest in Jolson’s music, as a whole new generation of listeners were exposed to his sound via the re-recordings of his old hits that he made for Decca.

These newer, updated versions of Jolson’s songs, often with markedly different arrangements and instrumentation, are nowadays the best-known and more widely available of his recordings. However, this volume of Columbia’s Art Deco Series, originally published in 1994 and currently out of print, digs deep into Jolson’s vast recorded legacy and presents some of his best sides cut for the label between 1913 and 1932, when Jolson was truly at the top of his game, complete with very detailed liner notes by Herbert G. Goldman and Will Friedwald. Made acoustically before the microphone allowed electricity to be used for recording sound, these cuts lack the higher fidelity of the later Deccas, yet they are clear evidence as to why Jolson reigned over the pop music world of the period. It is true that the arrangements are often dull and are performed by studio orchestras that cannot match the excitement always present in Jolson’s voice, but these sides chronicle his development as a recording artist and make for an extraordinarily enjoyable listening experience even almost a century after some of them were made.

The collection opens with Jolson’s 1913 rendition of “That Little German Band,” going back to the earliest days of his tenure with Columbia, and includes songs that he introduced and with which he became closely associated, such as “Yaaka Hula Hickey Dula,” “Swanee,” “Avalon,” “April Showers,” and “Toot, Toot, Tootsie! (Goo’Bye).” Jolson would re-record many of them later on in his career, but these are the earliest versions, and in many cases, the definitive ones. On some of the tracks, Jolson proves that he can also put across more sentimental ballads quite convincingly: as “Back to the Carolina You Love,” “Down Where the Swanee River Flows,” and “In Sweet September” demonstrate, Jolson was much more than simply a belter of lively rhythm numbers and maudlin mammy songs, a fact that is also evident in his excellent recording of “The Anniversary Song” for Decca in the 1940s. And of course, he is at his high-spirited best on novelty songs like “O-Hi-O (O-My!-Oh!) and “Where Did Robinson Crusoe Go with Friday on Saturday Night,” full of the witty double entendre lyrics that he always delivered so masterfully. (Incidentally, “Robinson Crusoe” spawned a very interesting western swing version by Texas Jim Lewis.)

In early 1924, Jolson ended his contract with Columbia and signed with Brunswick, which explains why the songs that he cut for the soundtrack of The Jazz Singer are not included here. However, the compilation closes very fittingly with three sides that Jolson made in 1932 for the American Recording Corporation backed by Guy Lombardo and His Royal Canadians: “Hallelujah I’m a Bum,” the title track of his then-current (and very interesting) movie; “You Are Too Beautiful,” a superb ballad that has since become a standard but that Jolson does not deliver as convincingly as other slow numbers in this collection; and a remake of his classic “Rock-a-Bye Your Baby with a Dixie Melody.” These are the only recordings included here made electrically, and they certainly capture Jolson’s voice much better, showing how much he had evolved as an entertainer since the 1913 records that kick off the set: he is now a singer in complete control of his art, and he knows exactly how to accentuate those elements and mannerisms that make his style unique.

After this date with Lombardo, Jolson would not set foot in a recording studio until the mid-1940s, although he would still be a regular fixture on radio. For those of us who were not fortunate enough to attend one of Jolson’s live performances, it is difficult to imagine just how exciting his stage show must have been: indeed, his records, movies, and radio appearances stand as faint documents of his idiosyncratic art, and contemporary journalistic accounts and reviews of his shows inevitably fail to convey the exuberance of his stage persona. Like Jacques Brel after him, Al Jolson was an artist that needed to be experienced in a live setting, yet we must be grateful that at least some of this excitement has been preserved for posterity on recordings like the ones that make up this excellent compilation.










Anonymous said...

A fine tribute to a by-gone entertainer who deserves another "listen." Jolson was labeled as "the world's greatest entertainer" by the Shubert publicity department during the run of "Robinson Crusoe, Jr," during its run in Chicago. The moniker stuck with him throughout his substantial career. Certainly, his later recordings are remembered best by contemporary audiences, but he made his name with the earlier work on Broadway.

Anonymous said...

A splendid review of Jolson's career! Your observations are keen and your appreciation of Jolson's one-of-a-kind talent is right on the money.
Your facts are also correct--which is a rarity these days re:Mr. Jolson.

The CD was a joy to listen to when I bought it years ago--and it continues to be one of the very best CDs that contain Jolson's Columbia tracks. And the booklet is well written, too--another rarity these days!

Thank you.

Anton Garcia-Fernandez said...

Dear friends,

Thank you very much for your very kind comments about my article on Jolson. Thanks also for the information about the origins of his being billed as "the world's greatest entertainer." I have no doubt that the people at the Shubert publicity department were absolutely right in their choice of words: at the time, Jolson could certainly be described as the greatest entertainer, and perhaps that is why the moniker stuck with him for so long.

I wrote this review, first of all, because I truly believe that Jolson is one of the most important and influential performers of the first half of the 20th century, and I chose this album because it is one of the best compilations on Jolson ever put together. While the later Decca sides are very enjoyable, I have always been partial to his earlier sides, especially the ones that he made during the acoustic era.

Once again, thanks for your interest in the article, as well as in Jolson and in vintage jazz and pop in general!


P.S.: By the way, the rest of Columbia's Art Deco Series CDs are also interesting, especially the discs they devoted to Eddie Cantor, Fred Astaire, Josephine Baker, and Marlene Dietrich.

Bruce Wexler said...

A wonderful review of a great cd by The World's Greatest Entertainer, the proof of which is not in the review, but in the reviewer. Meaning that a young man can still be captiviated by a man deceased these sixty years.
Great art, no matter it's source must pass the test of time. Jolson not only passes this test, he does so in great fashion. Time does not dilute the voice of this Super Star.
Thanks to Mr. Garcia for this wonderful review. I'm sure your thanks is to Mr. Jolson as well.

Bruce Wexler
Past President
The Intrnational Al Jolson Society

Anonymous said...

Congrats, Cowboy Anton.
Great tribute to Mr. Jolson. It brings a reverie of a certain show we, listeners of Nashville's WRVU, were pampered with one Thanksgiving night. I remember you hosted the show with the handsome likes of Mr. Silverado. Wonder what happened to him. Legend has it he is perverting young ladies (or, rather crooning and serenading) in Notre Dame.
Anyhow, may your next post be a homage to Albert Allick Bowlly.

Anton Garcia-Fernandez said...

Mr. Wexler

Thank you very much for your very kind words. As you say, great art must stand the test of time, and Jolson's music certainly does. That is why it has always captivated me, no matter how many years ago these sides were recorded. When you think of it, it is really amazing that "That Little German Band" was waxed in 1913, almost a hundred years ago! Listening to Jolson is like taking a trip back in time: it is not purely a nostalgic trip, but rather a very musically rewarding one. Jolson's talent is timeless, and as long as people like us care about his music, he and his art will never be forgotten.

Thanks again,

Anton Garcia-Fernandez.

Cap_Centollo said...

Great job Anton

Truth is ... your blog is something really special

Un abrazo desde Madrid

Anton Garcia-Fernandez said...


Thank you very much for your very kind words about my blog. Old jazz and pop music is a passion for me, and I enjoy writing about it and sharing my opinions with people like you.

Muchas gracias y pasate por aqui cuando quieras, amigo!